the therapy framework, emotional responses of clients and therapists to each about the goals and tasks of therapy. .. repeated patterns of relationship, as. PDF | The construct of transference has been central to theories of dynamic psychotherapy. This investigation evaluated the similarity between. Countertransference of Therapist with Dependent Pattern The client refuses to cooperate with much of the therapy. The client The client avoids a personal/ emotional relationship with you or denies that anything like that is.
According to the results proposed by Traceythe more successful the outcome, the more curvilinear the pattern of client and therapist session satisfaction high—low—high over the course of treatment.
When the outcome was worse, the curvilinear pattern was weaker. Kivlighan and Shaughnessy use the hierarchical linear modeling method an analysis technique for studying the process of change in studies where measurements are repeated to analyses the development of the alliance in a large number of cases.
According to their findings, some dyads presented the high—low—high pattern, others the opposite, and a third set of dyads had no specific pattern, although there appeared to be a generalized fluctuation in the alliance during the course of treatment.
In recent years, researchers have analyzed fluctuations in the alliance, in the quest to define patterns of therapeutic alliance development.
Kivlighan and Shaughnessy distinguish three patterns of therapeutic alliance development: They based their analysis on the first four sessions of short-term therapy and focused their attention on the third pattern, in that this appeared to be correlated with the best therapeutic outcomes.
In further studies of this development pattern, Stiles et al. Unlike Kivlighan and Shaughnessy, these authors considered therapies consisting of 8 and 16 sessions, using the ARM to rate the therapeutic bond, partnership, and confidence, disclosure, and patient initiative.
No significant correlation was observed between any of the four patterns and the therapeutic outcome. However, the authors observed a cycle of therapeutic alliance rupture—repair events in all cases: On the basis of this characteristic, the authors hypothesize that the V-shaped alliance patterns may be correlated with positive outcomes.
In particular, Stiles et al.
Patterns of Transference and Countertransference - Personal Growth Programs
The results of the study by De Roten et al. According to De Roten et al. De Roten et al. According to Castonguay et al. This has supported the idea that therapeutic alliance may be characterized by a variable pattern over the course of treatment, and led to the establishment of a number of research projects to study this phenomenon.
Discussion and Conclusion According to their meta-analysis based on the results of 24 studies, Horvath and Symonds demonstrate the existence of a moderate but reliable association between good therapeutic alliance and positive therapeutic outcome. More recent meta-analyses of studies examining the linkage between alliance and outcomes in both adult and youth psychotherapy Martin et al.
Thus, it is not by chance that in their meta-analysis, Horvath and Luborsky conclude that two main aspects of the alliance were measured by several scales regardless of the theoretical frameworks and the therapeutic models: This accounts for the difficulties associated with the concept of alliance, which is built interactively, and so any assessment must also consider the mutual influence of the participants.
In a helpful contribution, Hentschel points out that the problematic aspect of empirical studies investigating the alliance is their tendency to view the alliance construct as a treatment strategy and a predictor of therapeutic outcome: The use of neutral observers or the creation of counterintuitive studies is therefore recommended. From this historical excursus, it is clear that research into the assessment of the psychotherapeutic process is alive and well.
The development of a dynamic vision of the concept of therapeutic alliance is also apparent. The work of theorists and researchers has contributed toward enriching the definition of therapeutic alliance, first formulated in Research aimed at analyzing the components that make up the alliance continues to flourish and develop.
Numerous rating scales have been designed to analyses and measure the therapeutic alliance, scales that have enabled us to gain a better understanding of the various aspects of the alliance and observe it from different perspectives: Attention has recently turned toward the role of the therapeutic alliance in the various phases of therapy and the relationship between alliance and outcome.
So far, few studies have regarded long-term psychotherapy involving many counseling sessions. This topic, along with a more detailed examination of the relationship between the psychological disorder being treated and the therapeutic alliance, will be the subject of future research projects.
Equally important, in our opinion, will be the findings of studies regarding drop-out and therapeutic alliance ruptures, which must necessarily consider the differences between that perceived by the patient and that perceived by the therapist.
Conflict of Interest Statement The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Acknowledgments The authors thank Mauro Adenzato for his valuable comments and suggestions to an earlier version of this article.
A Research Handbook, eds Greenberg L. Guilford Press;— Bibring E. On the theory of the results of psychoanalysis. The generalizability of the psychoanalytic concept of the working alliance.
Patterns of Transference and Countertransference
Clinical Applications of Attachment Theory. Routledge and Kegan Paul Budman S. Cohesion, alliance and outcome in group psychotherapy. Psychiatry 52, — [ PubMed ] Burlingame G. Cohesion in group therapy. Is therapist alliance or whole group cohesion more influential in group psychotherapy outcomes? Is one assessment enough? Patterns of helping alliance development and outcome.
Franco Angeli Elvins R. The conceptualization and measurement of therapeutic alliance: The effects of psychotherapy: The predictive validity of six working alliance instruments.
The role of the therapeutic alliance in the treatment of schizophrenia. Relationship to course and outcome.
Psychiatry 47, — [ PubMed ] Freud S. Hogarth Press;— Gaston L. The concept of the alliance and its role in psychotherapy: Theory, Research and Practice, eds Horvath A. John Wiley and Sons;85— Gelso C. Components of the psychotherapy relationship: Group alliance and cohesion as predictors of drug and alcohol abuse treatment outcomes.
Varieties of transference patterns in psychotherapy.
Short psychotherapy interventions four sessions. The working alliance and the transference neurosis. Erlbaum;1—38 Hentschel U. On links to other constructs, determinants of its effectiveness, and its role for research in psychotherapy in general. Comparison of therapeutic factors in group and individual treatment processes. Theory, Research, and Practice, eds Horvath A. Wiley;— Horvath A. Therapist Contributions and Responsiveness to Patients, ed.
Oxford University Press;37—69 Horvath A. Guilford Press;— Horvath A. Development and validation of the working alliance inventory.
The role of the therapeutic alliance in psychotherapy. The development and decay of the working alliance during time-limited counseling. Thinking about thinking in therapy: Relation between working alliance and outcome in psychotherapy: Clinical Prediction in Psychotherapy.
Jason Aronson Howard I.
Therapeutic alliance mediates the relationship between interpersonal problems and depression outcome in a cohort of multiple sclerosis patients. Group climate, cohesion, alliance, and empathy in group psychotherapy: Meta-analysis of therapeutic relationship variables in youth and family therapy: The Kim alliance scale: Analysis of the development of the working alliance using hierarchical linear modeling.
Patterns of working alliance development: Therapeutic alliance in depression treatment: The generic model of psychotherapy: An empirical investigation of patterns of process and outcome relationships. For example, therapists can get into power struggles with clients with a Controlling or Rebel Pattern.
Therapists can become overly involved with clients with a Dependent Pattern. By seeing clearly the interpersonal patterns of any given client, you can be on the lookout for reactions of yours that might be interfering with their therapy. For example, if you have a Caretaking or Dependent Pattern, you might try to connect with a defended client too quickly because of your need for connection or your need to take care of them, thus frightening the client.
If you have a Prideful Pattern, you might become dependent on having your clients idealize you. This gives you important insight into issues of yours to work on outside of your sessions with clients. The client may have one particular pattern that is blocking their going deeper into the issues they need to explore or is keeping them from changing. Or the client might have a pattern that is undermining their therapeutic alliance with you or triggering certain reactions in you that are waylaying the therapy.
In the descriptions below, I will assume that you are the therapist. Dependent Pattern Transference of Dependent Client The client sees you as a nurturing mother or father and becomes overly dependent on you.
Countertransference Toward Dependent Client You become overly involved in caring for the client. Countertransference of Therapist with Dependent Pattern You become too emotionally involved with your client because of your dependency needs. The client picks up on clues about your pain or life struggles and tries to engage you in talking about them.
The client notices your insecurities and tries to assuage them. Countertransference Toward Caretaking Client You allow the client to take care of you more than is appropriate. Rebel Pattern The client refuses to cooperate with much of the therapy. The client fights with you and criticizes your approach.
Countertransference Toward Rebel Client You feel ineffective and incompetent. You become frustrated with the client. You get into arguments and power struggles with the client.